Only their face value of five cents is worth the majority of the nickels you find in your regular pocket change. However, a few rare nickels may be worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars because of unusual minting faults, historical importance, or restricted manufacturing runs.
You may receive an unexpected fortune if you’re fortunate enough to locate one. These precious nickels have turned into highly sought-after collectibles.
1. The Liberty Head Nickel of 1913: An Undiscovered Gem
One of the most well-known and valued coins in American history is the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel. The “holy grail” of American coin collecting has just five known specimens.
This coin’s existence is mysterious since it was not permitted for manufacturing in 1913 in contrast to other Liberty Head nickels. Because this coin is so rare, its value has skyrocketed; some of these nickels have sold for over $3 million at auction.
Advice: Since even reproductions may be valuable, it is recommended that you get a Liberty Head Nickel certified immediately if you ever see one.
2. The Odd Error of the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel
This special mistake coin is called the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel. One of the buffalo’s legs seems missing because of a mistake made during the minting process. The die’s excessive cleaning eroded the features of the fourth leg, giving the illusion of three legs.
Due to this defect, the coin is highly prized by collectors for its unique imperfection, and when in good condition, it may fetch up to $5,000.
Advice: Due to its widespread minting error, collectors highly sought this coin, making it one of the most sought-after nickels.
3. An Uncommon Mintmark Error: The 1942-D Over Horizontal D Nickel
Before fixing it, the Denver Mint inadvertently horizontally struck the “D” mintmark in 1942. The 1942-D Over Horizontal D Jefferson Nickel was the result of this error.
Due to the uncommon mintmark inaccuracy, it is a popular find among collectors. Check carefully for this feature if you have a 1942 nickel, which can be valued at up to $1,000.
Examine Closely: It is crucial to recognize this nickel’s peculiar mintmark look. A magnifying lens can help you see this distinctive characteristic.
4. The 1950-D Jefferson Nickel: High Value, Low Mintage
Because of its limited production, the 1950-D Jefferson Nickel is unique. It’s one of the rarest Jefferson nickels, with less than 2.6 million made.
This year’s coins may fetch over $1,500, and they are especially desirable if they are in mint condition. This nickel perfectly illustrates how a coin’s value may increase over time due to restricted manufacture.
Pro Tip: Look for 1950s Jefferson nickels, particularly those with the “D” mintmark.
5. A Collector’s Favorite: 1916 Doubled Die, Buffalo Nickel
The picture on the obverse (front) side of the 1916 Doubled Die Buffalo Nickel is doubled. This mistake resulted in a twofold picture because the die used to strike the coins was not correctly prepared.
With prices sometimes surpassing $4,000, it’s a highly sought-after and uncommon discovery. Serious collectors are particularly fond of this mistake coin.
Fun Fact: Pay particular attention to the coin’s inscriptions and date, as these are the areas where the doubling effect is most noticeable.
6. The 1943-P War Nickel: An Artifact from History
Due to the great need for nickel during World War II for the war effort, the U.S. Mint changed the composition of nickels in 1943. The 1943-P War Nickel is more valuable than other nickels from that era because it contains 35% silver.
The silver content makes it a sought-after piece, with prices starting at about $500, even though it is not as uncommon as some other pieces on this list.
Quick Tip: War nickels are recognized by their big mintmark over the Monticello building on the reverse side.
7. The 1949-S Jefferson Nickel: An Underappreciated Treasure
Another example of a coin with a low mintage is the 1949-S Jefferson Nickel. This coin, made at the San Francisco Mint, is an uncommon discovery because of its limited manufacturing run.
Because of its rarity and condition, collectors value it; premium examples can sell for over $1,000.
Remember: You can recognize this unusual nickel by looking for the “S” mintmark, which distinguishes coins from the San Francisco Mint.
8. The Buffalo Nickel of 1926-S: Limited and Priceless
Due to its limited production, the 1926-S Buffalo Nickel is a rare coin. These nickels, produced in the San Francisco Mint, are rare, particularly when in good shape. A valuable asset for any coin collector, high-quality specimens may fetch thousands of dollars.
Condition Matters: Many of these nickels have considerable wear, so it is uncommon to find one in good condition.
9. The SMS of 1964 The Mysterious Matte Finish of the Jefferson Nickel
The Special Mint Set (SMS) of 1964 The Jefferson Nickel is a special and enigmatic coin. There aren’t many known instances, and it has a matte texture, unlike other nickels.
These are thought to have been a component of an experimental minting procedure. It is extremely expensive because to its unique polish and rarity; prices sometimes surpass $8,200.
Examine carefully: This coin stands out due to its matte texture, so look for a smooth, frosted appearance.
Summary Table of Rare Nickels
| Coin Name | Year | Estimated Value | Unique Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1913 Liberty Head Nickel | 1913 | $3 million+ | Only five known to exist |
| 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel | 1937 | $5,000+ | Missing leg on buffalo |
| 1942-D Over Horizontal D Nickel | 1942 | $1,000+ | Overstamped mintmark |
| 1950-D Jefferson Nickel | 1950 | $1,500+ | Low mintage |
| 1964 SMS Jefferson Nickel | 1964 | $8,200+ | Matte finish, limited production |
Each of these nickels fascinatingly shows the history of American minting. These coins have become collectors’ gems due to mistakes, manufacturing modifications, or historical events. Look for any of these uncommon findings the next time you look through your change; you could unearth a hidden treasure!
FAQs
1. What makes these nickels so precious?
Collectors prize them because of their scarcity, minting flaws, historical relevance, or restricted manufacturing.
2. How can I determine the value or rarity of my nickel?
Look for distinctive elements like particular dates, minting mistakes, or mintmarks. For an assessment, you may also speak with a coin specialist.
3. Is it possible to locate these nickels that are in use today?
Even though they are uncommon, some priceless nickels may still be used, particularly in collections or older coin rolls.
4. I have unusual nickels; where can I sell them?
Rare nickels are sold on online markets focusing on collectibles, at coin auctions, or through trustworthy coin dealers.
5. Does my nickel need to be appraised?
Yes, a professional assessment may help verify its authenticity and assess its worth if you think you have a rare or valuable one.
READ MORE: 4 Zodiac Signs That Are More Likely to Cheat in Partnerships
